Answer to Question #61645 in Physics for David Schmidt

Question #61645
My students saw a video where a cell-phone was placed inside an acoustic guitar, camera facing up, and the strings plucked. The strings looked like they were vibrating in wave-shapes, sinusoidal and sawtooth and even more complex ones. Is this real or a phenomenon caused the the recording parameters of the camera-app?
1
Expert's answer
2016-08-30T10:39:03-0400
It’s a fake. From the two frets in view, we can see that the whole field of view of the camera is only a few centimeters in the foreground. From this and the movie, we would naively deduce that the largest amplitude waves on the strings had wavelengths of only a centimeter or so. In reality, the waves with these wavelengths will have very small amplitudes, and the large amplitude vibrations will have wavelengths of tens of centimeters.
So there you have it – the video is misleading, the effect comes from the camera work, not from physics.

Need a fast expert's response?

Submit order

and get a quick answer at the best price

for any assignment or question with DETAILED EXPLANATIONS!

Comments

David Schmidt
01.09.16, 17:11

My argument against it was that strings only can vibrate in simple back and forth patterns, that they dont have the string length to create those wave-form shapes and that the overtones of a guitar's strings are consistent, allowing for pitch but that the strings themselves don't form the waveshapes that an oscilloscope would be able to detect.

Leave a comment

LATEST TUTORIALS
New on Blog
APPROVED BY CLIENTS